Which side of the lettuce fence do you stand and a classic Caesar salad

Which side of the lettuce fence do you stand? The lettuce fence would be very wobbly and wouldn’t last long, just think of all those rabbits charging in and demolishing it! But never mind, you know I’m not being literal, don’t you….

Are you a soft and ruffled oak leaf lettuce chomper, a crisp round iceberg muncher, maybe you err on the side of baby gems or prefer to nibble on the wintry bitter taste of Radicchio, maybe a frilly Frissee tempts you, perhaps looseleaf fits your style, or is melt in your mouth butterhead your thing, or are you an upright crunchy Cos/Romaine kind of person?

Romaine Lettuce_Verte Mariachere_use (1)

Whatever your lettuce, I bet we all have a favourite way to eat, dress and prepare these leaves. Is it a splash of balsamic or a squeeze of lemon? Is it just “plain” leaves or do you chuck the contents of the fridge into the salad. Then there is the tricksy question of timing, do you start your meal with a salad, eat it during, or is your ideal to finish your meal with greens?

My what burning questions we have today on the promenade 🙂

Romaine Lettuce

I can’t decide if I find lettuce the easiest thing to grow or the trickiest. In the heat of summer when you crave fresh leaves and no cooking meals they have a tendency to bolt whilst in winter they can turn up their feet and suffer from frost. If I paid more attention to varieties and sowing dates I might have more answers; Eliot Coleman’s Four Season Harvest and Charles Dowding’s Salad Leaves For All Seasons are packed with information,  I just never seem to manage to put their wise words into action at the right time!

The newest addition to the Promenade is a French variety Verte Maraîchère a Cos / Romaine lettuce which is perfect for cooler season growing, but seems to be doing splendidly in the dry early heat of summer on the allotment. the one thing I am trying this year is to grow lettuce with the cucumbers and radish – apparently they are prefect companions,  I know they taste good on the plate together so I don’t see why they shouldn’t get on when growing.

USE_Caesar Salad (1)

So while the lettuce debate rages 🙂 I’ll leave you with a classic Caesar Salad. The best description I’ve ever read about how to prepare the salad comes from blogging buddy Sharyn of the Kale Chronicles, it starts “The salad that makes me set aside my food aversions is truly magical” and proceeds to tell us exactly how to prepare the salad, including the type of bowl to use. The one thing I’ve never managed to do is to crack the coddled egg directly into the salad, something squeamish in me stops me short. Maybe I don’t have enough confidence in myself to mix the egg yolk in properly or whether it’s the fact that it’s only partly cooked that stops me, but either way I cheat and crack the coddled egg into a small bowl and whisk it separately before I add it to the leaves. Oh, and I don’t use a wooden bowl…..

USE_Caesar Salad (2)

and to answer my own question, it’s a Romaine……..


And if it’s too late and your home-grown lettuce has bolted, you can always make lettuce soup!

For information on how to grow and save lettuce seeds here’s an article I wrote a while ago



  • Lovely post Claire. My youngest daughter, Emma, LOVES Caesar salad. My brother is a chef and owner of a fabulous Italian restaurant. Because a Caesar is not Italian, he does not have it on his menu. And of course, every time we go there, Emma asks her zio, in her see test voice, if he could make her a Caesar. And of course, he does. After having checked out the Guardian recipe, I will have to make it for her.

    • YOur daughter Emma has it made:) Sharyn’s recipe is the first one I ever made and works a treat, and the Guardian article basically replicates it. Nothing beats a fresh crsipy salad

  • I like BOTH crunchy and softer, leafy lettuces. As to making my own Caesar dressing … Kraft does a good enough job for me. 🙂 I have been known to make my own croutons though.

      • I shake my head when I see the packages of pre-seasoned croutons as they’re so easy to make yourself. Don’t get me started on the “kits”.

  • I sit firmly on the fence (the view is better up there) and then pick and choose from both sides! Adore caesar salad. In Spain salad is always served before the main course but I like it alongside the main event! Of course, I come down off the fence to sit at the table 😉

  • I am a Romaine kind of guy! My lettuces were finished in late April here. I have never thought of nor tried a Caesar salad with anything else but I may have to expand my views!

  • That’s easy – we’re on the side of whatever lettuce is easiest to pick. That means we’ve given up on all the mesclun and rocket cut-me-with-scissors lettuces and now plant just cos, preferably mini cos. Everyone loves them, we can pull a small head out for dinner without anything too backbreaking, and we can make your gorgeous Caesar salad with it. Oh, and it self-sows like crazy, so we often don’t have to even plant it. 🙂

  • Romaine is my favorite lettuce for a caesar salad, but as long as there are anchovies, I don’t care what kind of lettuce is used.

  • Love your questions and debate on something almost everyone has grown and most have overlooked as a topic of conversation! I am a melt in your mouth butterhead fan and a Cos/romaine fan too. I agree with you 100% that in the main summer season, lettuce from the garden seems to be gone (all eaten or bolted). I have read many times how to start it every couple of weeks but I don’t get to it. Maybe it is because other crops become too distracting or the heat take some of the zip out of me… Anyway, love this post and will check out the recipe. I too, am cautious/queasy with eggs so not sure if this may be a little to daring for me. Lovely photos too!

  • To be honest, I could do with eating more lettuce – but I am not on the side I am all about the iceberg 😀
    Crunchy, fresh and watery all in one!
    Your caesar salad looks so flavoursome 😀

    Choc Chip Uru

  • Romaine is usually my favorite, but with a little loose leaf of different colors and shapes mixed in. Growing lettuce here seems to be most successful when done accidentally. For me at least, intentional lettuce bolts and freezes, while the volunteers from said bolting (most often in the lawn and not the bed) keep us in salads for weeks. Something to be learned there…

  • What a timely post Claire! Like many other readers here, I too love them all. I love the mix of textures, colours and flavours, and am happy to have whatever the garden is offering at any time of the summer. We’re in the midst of a heatwave, so many of my lettuces are bolting right now (must check out that recipe for lettuce soup!), but another crop will be coming along in a little bit. I love greens entirely on their own with a bit of olive oil and lemon, and the simple dressing that I use again and again is just olive oil, white wine vinegar, a bit of dijon mustard, salt and pepper.

  • Hi Claire, I read the link with interest and the debate about whether to stick with the authentic recipe. I hate it when people vary a classic recipe but still call it by the classic name. Be as adventurous as you like but call it something else. I have been to a restaurant where they served Caesar salad with sun dried tomatoes in it! Heaven forbid. I like all lettuce but for Caesar I like Cos.

  • Well, cos is the lettuce I first used to make Caesar and I have remained true!! Love it as a simple first course! How to make it – please do not laugh if you have already not discovered this – Gordon Ramsay has a newish wonderful TV series/book out on ‘Ultimate Home Cooking’ [never a ‘f . .k’ in place: cooks with his four children!] – that has a wonderful Caesar salad recipe just with interesting croutons and cheese: lively, modern, simple, moorish!!!! Fully agree with Glenda about using classic names but not the classic recipe!!!!!!

  • I love Caesar Salad. Years and years and years ago I had my first Caesar in a very nice restaurant. I was quite young and was introduced to the pageantry of a Caesar dressed and tossed right at the table and I fell in love! I also remember Sharyn’s lovely description and recipe. I’m glad you’ve reminded me of it. I love all greens, but my preference is probably a crunchy Romaine–and I typically put in everything but the kitchen sink! Many nights the salad IS the dinner. I don’t grow lettuce well, simply because I don’t have the right condition in my yard to protect against the heat, but you’ve given me a thought that perhaps I should try again. You’ve inspired me, Claire. 🙂

  • Yes a lovely post! I love Caesar salad too but have to beware the lurking bacon that is so often found in it … this recipe is perfect for me, just those yummy salty anchovies thank you … and I prefer Cos lettuce mostly, but Oakleaf perennial types as well 🙂

  • What a lovely post Claire. If I had to chose, it would definitely be a baby gem – best of all the worlds – nice and crispy, not bitter, can balance scrumptious goodies in a single leaf or use it in a traditional salad or add it to a sarmie.
    Have a lovely day.
    🙂 Mandy xo

  • I like pretty much all lettuces, and most dressings too! As long as it’s not too floppy and drowned in oil and vinegar! Enjoy your salad Claire! 🙂

  • They’re all good – except frisee. Can’t grow it, don’t like it. I only tried for Hubby’s sake…
    I’ve been doing romaine with buttermilk dressing, but it seems to have bolted overnight. We’ll be switching to silky leaves with vinaigrette soon 🙂

  • Cos for Caesar salad, but for an everyday salad I throw everything at it, including nuts and dried fruit and raw veg, cucumbers and tomatoes. I make my own dressing, usually fresh every other day. But now I have an urge for a proper Caesar salad!

  • I love all varieties of lettuce but Romaine is my all time favorite. Have a great weekend Claire!

  • I planted an assortment of lettuces in an EarthBox, but they did indeed bolt. We had an early heat wave, and that, as they say, was that.

    I like romaine as well. Iceberg is probably my least favorite. Your pictures are lovely.

  • I love em all. I also like to do a thick row for cut and come again mixes. But I also do like just one good head of meaty lettuce like a romaine (esp a little green and red mixed)

  • Claire I do not think I have ever had a Caesar salad with any lettuce other than Romaine? I will now give it a try with some of the other types you mentioned. I bet it would be fantastic with Arugula as well? My lettuce season is long gone here in Tennessee. We are having 90 degree F weather and no lettuce I know can survive that. It is hard enough for people! Great photos.

  • There isn’t a one of the lettuces you mention that I won’t happily eat if it’s fresh and beautifully prepared/served. Depends on my mood and what’s available, I suppose. 😀

    One interesting salad variant that I’ve not tried to prepare myself but have been served deliciously is *grilled* Romaine. When I had it, it was simply split down the middle of the cleaned head (base intact enough to hold its form), grilled over open flame until very lightly charred and slightly softened, and served with a Caesar-like or creamy vinaigrette dressing, Gorgonzola crumbles and toasted walnuts tossed on top. Fabulous. I’ve had grilled radicchio as well, and more often, and like that too, so I imagine any of the sturdier greens (including kales, cabbages and their ilk) might well make a fine salad, treated thus. Not that I’ve any objection whatsoever to a good and utterly uncooked green salad!

    Hugs from here,

  • Viva la lettuce–I love them all. I am fond of the bitter ones especially with lots of olive oil and lemon. Happy lettuce chomping!

Submit a comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s